2012 NSCAA/Continental Tire Junior College Men's Division I All-America Team
First Team
| Pos. | First | Last | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Chris | McGaughey | So | Tyler Junior College | Armagh, Ireland |
| D | Casey | Osborne | So | Tyler Junior College | Atlanta, GA |
| D | Sam | Cusack | So | Yavapai College | Upminster, England |
| D | Seamus | Sharkey | So | Monroe Community College | Newtown, Ireland |
| D | Brad | Vorv | Fr | Louisburg College | Chevy Chase, MD |
| M | Troy | Tucker | So | Darton College | Smiths Perish, Bermuda |
| M | Oneil | Fisher | So | Tyler Junior College | St. Catherine, Jamaica |
| M | Eduardo | Alvarez | So | Louisburg College | Tegucigalpa, Honduras |
| M | Javier | Lopez | So | Marshalltown CC | Granada, Spain |
| F | Ngwese | Ebangwese | So | Monroe Community College | Rochester, NY |
| F | Amara | Soumah | So | Illinois Central CC | Aurora, CO |
| F | Marcelo | Norton | So | Iowa Western CC | Rio de Janeiro, Brazil |
Second Team
| Pos. | First | Last | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Will | Lukowski | Fr | Iowa Western CC | Greenfield, MO |
| D | Gonzalo | Gelso | So | Barton County Community College | Wellington, FL |
| D | Wayne | Hall | So | Tyler Junior College | Newcastle, England |
| D | Daniel | Arrazola | So. | Jefferson College | Santa Cruz, Bolivia |
| D | Calum | Nimmo | So. | Iowa Central CC | Fleet, England |
| M | Rene | Legien | So | Louisburg College | Hamelin, Germany |
| M | Cameron | Duckworth | So | Iowa Central CC | West Des Moines, IA |
| M | Erik | Luzanilla | So | Arizona Western | San Luis, AZ |
| M | Joel | Perez | So | Spartanburg Methodist College | Greenville, SC |
| F | Jowayne | Laidley | So | Darton College | Orlando, FL |
| F | Justin | Mitchell | So | Cincinnati State Technical & CC | Beaver Creek, Ohio |
| F | Marc | Fenelus | So | Western Texas College | Turks and Caicos |