2012 NSCAA/Continental Tire Junior College Women's Division I All-America Teams
First Team
| Pos. | First | Last | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Chloe | Crook | So. | Monroe Community College | London, England |
| D | Heather | Williams | Fr. | Brevard Community College | Homestead, Fla. |
| D | Deylsa | Reyes Delgado | So. | Laramie County Community College | San Juan, Puerto Rico |
| D | Morgan | Olsen | So. | Iowa Western Community College | Providence, Utah |
| M | Jessica | DeLeon | So. | Paradise Valley Community College | Phoenix, Ariz. |
| M | Stacie | Murray | So. | Tyler Junior College | Southampton, England |
| M | Megan | Snyder* | So. | Butler Community College | Overland Park, Kan. |
| F | Taylor | Samsel | So. | Iowa Western Community College | Sandy, Utah |
| F | Lois | Edvardsson | So. | Brevard Community College | Gothenburg, Sweden |
| F | Alexandra | Doller | So. | Paradise Valley Community College | Tempe, Ariz. |
| F | Makela | Howell | So. | Monroe College | Basingstoke, England |
Second Team
| Pos. | First | Last | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Katherine | VanMeter | Fr. | Tyler Junior College | Longview, Texas |
| D | Ashley | Stein | Fr. | Paradise Valley Community College | Scottsdale, Ariz. |
| D | Katie | Foytlin | So. | St. Louis Community College | Belleville, Ill. |
| D | Teresa | Offerman | So. | Butler Community College | Wichita, Kan. |
| M | Caitlin | McGarry | So. | Community College of Rhode Island | Warwick, R.I. |
| M | Nugene | Nugent | So. | Navarro College | Kingston, Jamaica |
| M | Kim | Treutel | So. | Darton College | Newnan, Ga. |
| F | Taylor | Hockley | Fr. | Laramie County Community College | Casper, Wyo. |
| F | Miranda | Burrough | So. | Kaskaskia College | Poplar Bluff, Mo. |
| F | Alison | Sharpe | Fr. | Monroe Community College | Brockport, N.Y. |
| F | MacKenzie | Knepper | So. | Southwestern Illinois College | Swansea, Ill. |