2012 NSCAA/Continental Tire NCAA Division III Men's All-America Teams
Men's Senior College All-Time NSCAA All-Americans (PDF) - Updated Spring 2012
* - Indicates repeat All-American selection
First Team
| Name | Class | Pos. | School | Hometown |
| Matthew Cardone | So. | K | Trinity University (Texas) | San Antonio, Texas |
| Julien Aoyama | Jr. | D | Amherst College | Narberth, Pa. |
| Ben Lewis | Sr. | D | MIT | West Hartford, Conn. |
| Mark Lubetkin | Sr. | D | Montclair State University | Livingston, N.J. |
| Kevin Cavers | Jr. | M | Loras College | Arlington Heights, Ill. |
| Daniel Mendoza | Jr. | M | Montclair State University | Hackensack, N.J. |
| Jeremy Payne | So. | M | Messiah College | Middleburg, Pa. |
| Nathan Bascom | Sr. | F | Ohio Northern University | Cincinnati, Ohio |
| Jalon Brown | So. | F | Christopher Newport University | Yorktown, Va. |
| Spencer Noon | Sr. | F | Amherst College | Farmington, Conn. |
| Yuri Ribeiro* | Jr. | F | Trinity University (Texas) | Salvador, Brazil |
Second Team
| First | Class | Pos. | School | Hometown |
| Peter Maxted | Jr. | K | Swarthmore College | Port Washington, N.Y. |
| Alex Laird* | Sr. | D | St. Lawrence University | Monroe, N.Y. |
| Zander Mrlik | Sr. | D | Vassar College | San Francisco, Calif. |
| Kamali Webson | Sr. | D | Roger Williams University | Bellingham, Wash. |
| Austin Windsor | Sr. | D | Ohio Northern University | Dublin, Ohio |
| Ryan Greenhill | Sr. | M | Hiram College | Solon, Ohio |
| Matt Hamilton | Jr. | M | Plattsburgh State University | Keesville , N.Y. |
| Nick Holtrop | Sr. | M | Calvin College | Hudsonville, Mich. |
| Brian Ramirez | So. | M | Messiah College | Harrisburg, Pa. |
| Eric Anderson** | Sr. | F | Babson College | Scituate, Mass. |
| Victor Daza | Sr. | F | Stevens Institute Of Technology | North Plainfield, N.J. |
| Branden McGarrity | Fr. | F | Carleton College | Glenview, Ill. |
| William McGuiness | Sr. | F | University Of Scranton | Forty Fort, Pa. |
| Stephen Zapata | Sr. | F | Albertus Magnus College | Hamden, Conn. |
Third Team
| First | Class | Pos. | School | Hometown |
| Mac Church | Sr. | K | Ohio Northern University | Whitehouse, Ohio |
| Neil Bartholomay | Jr. | D | Carleton College | Minneapolis, Minn. |
| Christopher Conover | Sr. | D | Roanoke College | Dagsboro, Del. |
| Richard Marquez | Jr. | D | University of Redlands | Fontana, Calif. |
| Lucas Thompson | Sr. | D | Gustavus Adolphus College | Sioux Falls, S.D. |
| Logan Andryk | Fr. | M | Milwaukee School of Engineering | Hartland, Wis. |
| Filip Lindmark | Sr. | M | North Park University | Skovde, Ill. |
| Rory O'Neill* | Sr. | M | Wesleyan University | Silver Springs, Md. |
| Brian Vasquez | So. | M | Mississippi College | Clinton, Miss. |
| Peter Christman | Sr. | M | Williams College | Falmouth, Mass. |
| Adam Blackman | So. | F | Wheaton College (Ill.) | Urbana, Ill. |
| Jake Gamble | Sr. | F | Penn State-Behrend | Erie, Pa. |
| Sebastiaan Jansen | Sr. | F | Union College | Schenectady, N.Y. |
| Mahir Mameledzija | Jr. | F | Lake Forest College | Skokie, Ill. |
| Sam Ocel | Sr. | F | Brandeis University | North Attleboro, Mass. |
| Mike Ryan | Fr. | F | Rutgers University-Camden | Marlton, N.J. |
Additional Links
Men's Senior College All-Time NSCAA All-Americans (PDF) - Updated Spring 2012