2012 NSCAA/Continental Tire NCCAA Women's Division I All-America Team
Women's Senior College All-Time NSCAA All-Americans (PDF) - Updated Spring 2012
* - Indicates repeat All-America selection
First Team
| Position | First | Last | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Tiffany | Kracy* | Sr. | Point Loma Nazarene University | Whittier, Calif. |
| D | Leah | Porter | Jr. | Point Loma Nazarene University | Yorba Linda, Calif. |
| D | Sara | Eguren | Jr. | Southern Nazarene University | Houston, Texas |
| D | Karoline | Harnes | So. | Palm Beach Atlantic University | Haroy, Norway |
| M | Bernadette | Witz | Jr. | California Baptist University | Temecula, Calif. |
| M | Daelyn | Paul | Sr. | California Baptist University | Upland, Calif. |
| M | Carianne | Sobey | Fr. | Grace College | Woodstock, Ill. |
| M | Kathryn | Allison | Sr. | Covenant College | Birmingham, Ala. |
| F | Kelly | Jenks | Jr. | California Baptist University | Palo Alto, Calif. |
| F | Brooke | Gann | So. | Trevecca Nazarene Univesity | Chattanooga, Tenn. |
| F | Natalie | Sun | Sr. | Azusa Pacific University | Encintas, Calif. |
| F | Mallory | Rondeau | Fr. | Grace College | Winona Lake, Ind. |
Second Team
| Position | First | Last | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Michelle | Wieland | Sr. | Azusa Pacific University | Lake Forest, Calif. |
| D | Melissa | Laxamana | Jr. | California Baptist University | Fullerton, Calif. |
| D | Alyssa | Figueroa | Jr. | Houghton College | Piscataway, N.J. |
| D | Bekah | Gonzales | Jr. | Trinity Christian College | Visalia, Calif. |
| M | Bekah | Stewart | So. | Southern Nazarene University | Miami, Okla. |
| M | Shannon | Righetti | Sr. | Azusa Pacific University | San Jose, Calif. |
| M | Ashley | Shoaf | Sr. | Palm Beach Atlantic University | Virgina Beach, Va. |
| F | Brittany | Kinmond | Jr. | Roberts Wesleyan College | Rochester, N.Y. |
| F | Libby | Storie | Jr. | Oklahoma Wesleyan University | Gillette, Wyo. |
| F | Kimberly | Allard | So. | California Baptist University | Riverside, Calif. |
| F | Stephany | Ellison | So. | Houghton College | Whitesville, N.Y. |
| UT | Heidi | Witschi | Sr. | Azusa Pacific University | Visalia, Calif. |