2012 NSCAA/Continental Tire NCCAA Men's Division II All-America
Men's Senior College All-Time NSCAA All-Americans (PDF) - Updated Spring 2012
* - Indicates repeat All-American selection(s)
| Position | First | Last | Class | School | Hometown |
| K | Steven | Fabian | Jr. | Ohio Christian University | Grove City, OH |
| D | David | McFarland | Jr. | Moody Bible Institute | Nantes, France |
| D | Korben | Koenig | Jr. | Ozark Christian College | Fort Collins, Colo. |
| D | Caleb | Veer | Jr. | Manhattan Christian College | Newton, Kan. |
| D | James | Kuhle | Jr. | Northland International University | Gold River, Calif. |
| M | Ethan | Montesinos | Jr. | Moody Bible Institute | Savannah, Ga. |
| M | Josh | Netz | Jr. | Northland International University | Clayton, N.J. |
| M | Christian | Stepaniak | So. | North Central University | Woodbury, Minn. |
| M | Drew | Custer | Sr. | Clearwater Christian College | Greenville, S.C. |
| F | Jacob | Persson | So. | Moody Bible Institute | Sherwood, Ark. |
| F | Emanuel | Harris | Sr. | Ohio Christian University | Columbus, Ohio |
| F | Jorge | Saucedo | Fr. | Northland International University | Paysandu, Uruguay |
| F | Dave | Blamo | Sr. | Ohio Christian University | Monoriva, Liberia |
| GK | Ricky | Wiseman | Jr. | Manhattan Christian College | London, England |