2012 NSCAA High School Boys Scholar All-America Team
Goalkeepers
| First | Last | High School | City, State | GPA |
| Charlie | Coon | Williamston High School | Williamston, MI | 4.00 |
| Christian | Espinoza | Battle Mountain High School | Avon, CO | 3.75 |
| Nick | Galentine | Salesianum School | Newark, DE | 4.27 |
| James | Hickok | Staples High School | Westport, CT | 3.88 |
Defenders
| First | Last | High School | Hometown | GPA |
| Cole | Bortz | Colorado Academy | Littleton, CO | 4.00 |
| Corey | Deaton | Marion High School | Marion, IN | 4.55 |
| Brandon | Hudik | Bordentown Regional High School | Bordentown, NJ | 4.24 |
| Hudson | Owens | Wesleyan Christian Academy | Greesboro, NC | 4.75 |
| Calvin | Steber | Danville High School | Danville, KY | 4.77 |
| Campbell | Weyland | St. Xavier High School | Pewee Valley, KY | 3.98 |
Midfielders
| First | Last | High School | City, State | GPA |
| David | Burton | Tree of Life Christian School | Columbus, OH | 4.09 |
| Kaelon | Fox | St. Xavier High School | Louisville, KY | 3.75 |
| Christian | Gateskill-Fuqua | Danville High School | Danville, KY | 3.77 |
| Charlie | Gruner | Pomfret School | Stevenson, MD | 3.82 |
| Brock | Hersch | Beachwood High School | Beachwood, OH | 3.81 |
| Jacob | Lafrancis | Newton Conover High School | Conover, NC | 4.67 |
| James | Larson | Polson High School | Polson, MT | 4.00 |
| Connor | Leeman | Montville High School | Oakdale, CT | 4.21 |
| Phil | Longenecker | Grayslake Central High School | Grayslake, IL | 4.45 |
| David | Means | St. Xavier High School | Louisville, KY | 4.82 |
| Kevin | Mercadante | Chaminade High School | Garden City, NY | 3.89 |
| Koty | Millard | Cardinal Newman High School | Hopkins, SC | 4.58 |
| Kyle | Richardville | Vincennes Lincoln High School | Vincennes, IN | 3.98 |
| Landon | Souder | Mercer County Senior High School | Harrodsburg, KY | 4.1 |
| Aaron | Sparks | Jacksonville High School | Jacksonville, NC | 4.3 |
| Ryan | Sullivan | St. Xavier High School | Prospect, KY | 4.5 |
| Mike | Vieth | Reitz Memorial High School | Evansville, IN | 3.95 |
Forwards
| First | Last | High School | City, State | GPA |
| Samuel | Bascom | Madeira High School | Madeira, OH | 3.97 |
| Andrew | Cohen | Ellington High School | Ellington, CT | 4.15 |
| Sean | Doyle | Monroe Township High School | Monroe Township, NJ | 4.00 |
| Jihun | Lee | Carlisle School | Axton, VA | 4.14 |
| Samuel | Miller | East Jessamine High School | Nicholasville, KY | 3.91 |
| Christian | Okeke | Wichita Falls Rider | Wichita Falls, TX | 4.18 |
| Davi | Ramos | Fayetteville Academy | Fayetteville, NC | 4.00 |
| Matt | Saunders | Lawrence High School | Fairfield, ME | 4.00 |
| Jordan | Stewart | The Geneva School | Altamonte Springs, FL | 4.42 |