2012 NSCAA High School Girls Scholar All-America Team
Goalkeepers
| First | Last | High School | City, State | GPA |
| Rebecca | Ewel | Winston Churchill High School | Potomac, MD | 4.55 |
| Katie | Nickles | Bethlehem Central High School | Slingersland, NY | 3.87 |
Defenders
| First | Last | High School | City, State | GPA |
| Amanda | Buck | Islip High School | Bayshore, NY | 3.75 |
| Laura | Felix | St. Henry District High School | Burlington, KY | 4.29 |
| Caroline | Kimble | Our Lady of Good Counsel | Ashton, MD | 4.09 |
| Katherine | McClain | Vero Beach High School | Vero Beach, FL | 4.53 |
| Anna | Soccorsi | The Pennington School | Pennington, NJ | 3.94 |
Midfielders
| First | Last | High School | City, State | GPA |
| Emma | Bloom | Lake Highland Preparatory School | Maitland, FL | 3.90 |
| Jaden | DeGracie | Highland High School | Mesa, AZ | 4.40 |
| Victoria | Doss | Carmel High School | Carmel, IN | 4.39 |
| Natalie | Estes | Zionsville Community High School | Zionsville, IN | 3.93 |
| Emily | Godwin | Buckhannon-Upshur High School | Buckhannon, WV | 4.14 |
| Hope | Gouterman | Sherwood High School | Olney, MD | 4.30 |
| Sarah | Henson | Hickory High School | Hickory, NC | 4.50 |
| Alex | Jenkins | Smithfield High School | Smithfield, RI | 4.00 |
| Libby | Leedom | St. Henry District High School | Florence, KY | 4.21 |
| Emily | Marshall | Tuscarora High School | Adamstown, MD | 4.06 |
| Katherine | Nahigian | Cardinal Newman School | Elgin, SC | 4.01 |
| Ashley | Ritter | Vero Beach High School | Vero Beach, FL | 4.73 |
| Delaney | Sheehan | Mandeville High School | Mandeville, LA | 4.59 |
| Stephanie | Sorrells | Birdville High School | Hurst, TX | 4.55 |
| Audrey | Thomas | Issaquah High School | Bellevue, WA | 4.00 |
Forwards
| First | Last | High School | City, State | GPA |
| Madison | Baldwin | Zanesville High School | Zanesville, OH | 4.13 |
| Meaghan | Carrigan | Christ Church Episcopal School | Greenville, SC | 4.04 |
| Emma | Dwenger | Columbus East High School | Columbus, Ind. | 4.15 |
| Laura | Hill | PikeView High School | Athens, WV | 4.01 |
| Jenna | Linxwiler | Center Grove | Greenwood, IN | 3.86 |
| Melinda | Lukas | North Fort Myers High School | Cape Coral, FL | 4.00 |
| Andrea | O'Brien | Concord-Carlisle High School | Concord, MA | 3.81 |
| Margaret | Purce | Our Lady of Good Counsel High School | Olney, MD | 4.40 |