| 2004 NSCAA/adidas® | ||||||||||
| NCAA Division III Men | ||||||||||
|
||||||||||
| First Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| K | Gary Kane* | Sr. | Johns Hopkins | Lansdale, Pa. | ||||||
| D | Chris Brown | Sr. | Johns Hopkins | Harrisburg, Pa. | ||||||
| D | Jeff Grosser | Jr. | Johns Hopkins | Beach Haven, N.J. | ||||||
| D | Scott Wimsey | Jr. | Arcadia | Philadelphia, Pa. | ||||||
| M | Sebastian Driver-Salazar | Sr. | Westminster | Bethesda, Md. | ||||||
| M | Manabi Gill | Jr. | Johns Hopkins | East Brunswick, N.J. | ||||||
| M | Kai Kasiguran | Fr. | Messiah | Oakwood Village, Ohio | ||||||
| F | Brian Healy | Jr. | Elizabethtown | Newark, Pa. | ||||||
| F | David McClellan | Jr. | Messiah | Middleburg, Pa. | ||||||
| F | Dan McGarry | Fr. | Arcadia | Philadelphia, Pa. | ||||||
| F | Derek Swanner | Jr. | Drew | Monroe, N.J. | ||||||
| Second Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| K | Jason Fesler | Sr. | Lycoming | Mechanicsburg, Pa. | ||||||
| D | Dan Bash | Jr. | PSU-Behrend | Pittsburgh, Pa. | ||||||
| D | Chris Claussen | Jr. | Messiah | McPherson, Kan. | ||||||
| D | Stefan Weitzel | Fr. | Westminster | Nuremburg, Germany | ||||||
| M | Andrew Kummerer | Jr. | Elizabethtown | Glenmore, Pa. | ||||||
| M | Fran Pitonyak* | Sr. | Lebanon Valley | Langhorne, Pa. | ||||||
| M | Lavel Williams | Jr. | Bethany | Toronto, Ontario | ||||||
| F | Jonathan Browne | So. | Carnegie Mellon | Pittsburgh, Pa. | ||||||
| F | Brandon Corday | Fr. | Franklin&Marshall | Marton Gr., Ill. | ||||||
| F | Nate Snyder | So. | Susquehanna | Catawissa, Pa. | ||||||
| F | James Steidel** | Sr. | Carnegie Mellon | Pittsburgh, Pa. | ||||||
| Third Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| K | Tim Wassell | Jr. | PSU-Altoona | Hollidaysburg, Pa. | ||||||
| D | Frank Auteri | Sr. | Drew | Ridgewood, N.J. | ||||||
| D | Scott Morrow | So. | McDaniel | Mechanicsburg, Pa. | ||||||
| D | Nick Taraquino | Sr. | Moravian | Pt. Pleasant, N.J. | ||||||
| M | Matt Abate | So. | Arcadia | Marlton, N.J. | ||||||
| M | Chris Brunetti | So. | Arcadia | Philadelphia, Pa. | ||||||
| M | Leon Mach | Sr. | McDaniel | Baltimore, Md. | ||||||
| F | Chris Borchik | Sr. | Gettysburg | Reisertown, Md. | ||||||
| F | James Henshaw* | Jr. | Muhlenberg | Allentown, Pa. | ||||||
| F | Derek Roberts-Dukes* | Jr. | Wesley | Cherokee, N.J. | ||||||
| F | Adam Zeleznick** | Jr. | Pittsburg-Greensburg | South Park, Pa. | ||||||
| * Indicates prior selections | ||||||||||