| 2004 NSCAA/adidas® | ||||||||||
| NCAA Division III Men | ||||||||||
|
||||||||||
| First Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| K | Austin Person | So. | North Park | Omaha, Neb. | ||||||
| D | John George | Sr. | St. Norbert | Oconomowoc, Wis. | ||||||
| D | Jeff Neumann | Sr. | Wheaton | High Point, N.C. | ||||||
| D | Peter Ostroske | Sr. | Chicago | New Orleans, La. | ||||||
| M | Alex Degurian | So. | Aurora | Naperville, Ill. | ||||||
| M | Ben Preyss | Sr. | Chicago | Chagrin Falls, Ohio | ||||||
| M | Jeremy Tolleson* | Sr. | Wheaton | Atlanta, Ga. | ||||||
| F | Erik Elizondo* | Sr. | Dominican | Cicero, Ill. | ||||||
| F | Tyler Merkatoris* | Jr. | St. Norbert | Green Bay, Wis. | ||||||
| F | Justin Risma* | Jr. | Wheaton | Rochester, Minn. | ||||||
| F | Peter Schrieber* | Jr. | Concordia Wisconsin | Milwaukee, Wis. | ||||||
| Second Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| K | Ryan Dineen* | Sr. | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | Brookfield, Wis. | ||||||
| D | Alan Mila | Sr. | Illinois Wesleyan | Bartlett, Ill. | ||||||
| D | Travis Moulton | So. | Concordia Wisconsin | Watertown, Wis. | ||||||
| D | Ben Olson | Sr. | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | Robbinsdale, Minn. | ||||||
| M | Matias Alvarez | Sr. | Aurora | Aurora, Ill. | ||||||
| M | Sam Figueroa | Jr. | Lake Forest | Bartlett, Ill. | ||||||
| M | Grant Markgraf | Sr. | St. Norbert | St. Charles, Ill. | ||||||
| F | Demetrius Banks | Jr. | Milwaukee School of Engineering | Milwaukee, Wis. | ||||||
| F | Tommy Becker* | Sr. | Ripon | Darien, Wis. | ||||||
| F | Rodrigo Gomes* | So. | Lawrence | Buenos Aires, Argentina | ||||||
| F | Aaron Whetstone* | Sr. | Beloit | Madison, Wis. | ||||||
| Third Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| K | Jonathan Maendel | Sr. | Dominican | Evanston, Ill. | ||||||
| D | C.J. Lipinski | Jr. | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | New Berlin, Wis. | ||||||
| D | Chris Schultz | Jr. | Carroll | Lake Mills, Wis. | ||||||
| D | Henrik Wihlborg | Sr. | North Park | Ljungby, Sweden | ||||||
| M | Nicolas Aguilar | Jr. | North Central | Woodridge, Ill. | ||||||
| M | Dave Makovec | So. | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | New Berlin, Wis. | ||||||
| M | Simi Wakawa | Jr. | Elmhurst | Toledo, Ohio | ||||||
| F | Scott Kress | So. | Lakeland | Kiel, Wis. | ||||||
| F | Stuart Loe | Sr. | Wisconsin-Whitewater | Oshkosh, Wis. | ||||||
| F | Mark Losby | Sr. | Edgewood | Mount Horeb, Wis. | ||||||
| F | Matt Moncada | Jr. | North Park | Crystal Lake, Ill. | ||||||
| * indicates prior selections | ||||||||||