| 2004 NSCAA/adidas® | ||||||||||
| NCAA Division III Men | ||||||||||
|
||||||||||
| First Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| K | Jason Cranford* | Jr. | Salisbury | Chesapeake City, Md. | ||||||
| D | Tony Falvino | Jr. | Greensboro | Johnsonville, New Zealand | ||||||
| D | Caleb Hill | Sr. | Virginia Wesleyan | Virginia Beach, Va. | ||||||
| D | Markus Hunkeler | Sr. | Salisbury | Damascus, Md. | ||||||
| M | Matt Brock* | Sr. | Bridgewater | Signal Mountain, Tenn. | ||||||
| M | Karl Dix* | Jr. | Emory | Snellville, Ga. | ||||||
| M | Dan Lader* | Sr. | Salisbury | Bel Air, Md. | ||||||
| F | Matt Feraci | Sr. | Guilford | Midlothian, Va. | ||||||
| F | Lucas Fuentes | Fr. | North Carolina Wesleyan | Houston, Texas | ||||||
| F | Scott McDowell* | Jr. | York | York, Pa. | ||||||
| F | Chris Mills | Jr. | Salisbury | Hagerstown, Md. | ||||||
| Second Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| K | Dan Ruch | Jr. | Lynchburg | Ridgefield Park, N.J. | ||||||
| D | TJ McCallum* | Sr. | Maryville | Columbia, Tenn. | ||||||
| D | Peter Miller* | Sr. | Washington & Lee | Towson, Md. | ||||||
| D | Donny Smith | Jr. | Roanoke | Roanoke, Va. | ||||||
| M | Mario Acosta | Fr. | North Carolina Wesleyan | Houston, Texas | ||||||
| M | Matt Cooper | Jr. | Randolph-Macon | Edgewood, Md. | ||||||
| M | John Drummond | Sr. | Piedmont | Lumphinnans, Scotland | ||||||
| F | Davorin Husadinovic | Fr. | North Carolina Wesleyan | Sterling, Va. | ||||||
| F | Galen Reid | So. | Greensboro | Greensboro, N.C. | ||||||
| F | Brian Wolcott* | Sr. | St. Mary's (Md.) | Silver Spring, Md. | ||||||
| F | Nick Yanitello | Sr. | Christopher Newport | Williamsburg, Va. | ||||||
| Third Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| K | Brian Shumate* | Sr. | Christopher Newport | Chesterfield, Va. | ||||||
| D | Justin Chezem* | Sr. | Christopher Newport | Montclair, Va. | ||||||
| D | Sam Hale | So. | Greensboro | Upper Marlboro, Md. | ||||||
| D | Kevin McCarthy | Sr. | Emory | St. Louis, Mo. | ||||||
| M | Thomas Bennett | Sr. | Methodist | Virginia Beach, Va. | ||||||
| M | Billy Lucas* | Sr. | Christopher Newport | Yorktown, Va. | ||||||
| M | Elliott Stallings* | Jr. | Roanoke | Blacksburg, Va. | ||||||
| F | Chris Keating | Jr. | Roanoke | Chatham, N.J. | ||||||
| F | Justin Kessler | Jr. | Marymount | Oak Hill, Va. | ||||||
| F | Brian Pirkle* | Sr. | Washington & Lee | Lee, Va. | ||||||
| F | Steffan Schollaert | Sr. | Guilford | Oak Ridge, N.C. | ||||||
| * Indicates prior selections | ||||||||||