| 2005 NSCAA/adidas® | ||||
| NCAA Division III Men | ||||
| All-Metro Region | ||||
| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown |
| GK | Matt Kasperavicius | So. | The College of New Jersey | Jackson, N.J. |
| D | Thomas Blumestein | Sr. | Rutgers-Camden | Audubon, N.J. |
| D | Rich Dominiak*** | Sr. | Rowan | Mt. Laurel, N.J. |
| D | Nick Gkionis* | Jr. | Stevens Institute Of Technology | Jackson, N.J. |
| M | Patrick Baldiserra* | So. | Rutgers-Camden | Milmay, N.J. |
| M | Steve Lebezeit* | Sr. | Stevens Institute Of Technology | Pompton Lakes, N.J. |
| M | Joe McGinley | So. | The College of New Jersey | Cranford, N.J. |
| F | Scott Adams*** | Sr. | Richard Stockton | Myerstown, N.J. |
| F | Kyle Flynn | Jr. | U.S. Merchant Marine Academy | Poughquag, N.Y. |
| F | Matt Luber | Jr. | The College of New Jersey | Delran, N.J. |
| F | Chris Rosenthal* | Sr. | New Jersey City | Kearny, N.J. |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown |
| GK | Bruce Neves | So. | New Jersey City | Highland, Calif. |
| D | Mike Hogan*** | Sr. | Montclair State | Lodi, Wis. |
| D | Konrad Kruczek | So. | Kean | Long Beach, Calif. |
| D | Ryan Lahey | Fr. | Ramapo | West Des Moines, Iowa |
| M | Billy Anthes | Jr. | Montclair State | Federal Way, Wash. |
| M | Nick Dandapani | Sr. | U.S. Merchant Marine Academy | Highland, Calif. |
| M | Jerrit Thayer | So. | New York University | Annandale, Va. |
| F | Juan Espinoza | Fr. | New Jersey City | Port Townsend, Wash. |
| F | Juan Gomez | Sr. | CCNY | Sumner, Wash. |
| F | Jay Hooper* | Jr. | William Paterson | Norwich, England |
| F | Brian Marks*** | Sr. | Stevens Institute Of Technology | Corvallis, Ore. |
| Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown |
| GK | Joseph Halverson | Jr. | U.S. Merchant Marine Academy | San Antonio, Texas |
| D | Emilio Andino | Fr. | New York Maritime | Roselle, N.J. |
| D | Nick Katsonos | Jr. | New York University | Flushing, N.Y. |
| D | Dan Morse | Sr. | Richard Stockton | Cherry Hill, N.J. |
| M | Benji Eggart | Fr. | Ramapo | Paterson, N.J. |
| M | Nick Martinelli*** | Sr. | Rowan | Lancaster, Pa. |
| M | Scott Viera** | Sr. | Manhattanville | Staten Island, N.Y. |
| F | Matt Connor | Sr. | The College of New Jersey | Wayne, N.J. |
| F | Asmir Dzemovski | Sr. | Staten Island | Staten Island, N.Y. |
| F | Jorge Montesinos | Jr. | Kean | Dover, N.J. |
| F | Caner Yilmaz | Jr. | Baruch | Queens, N.Y. |
| * indicates prior selections | ||||