| 2005 NSCAA/adidas® | ||||
| NCAA Division III Men | ||||
| All-New England West Region | ||||
| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown |
| GK | Zach Toth | Jr. | Middlebury | Carlisle, Mass. |
| D | Steve Balgach* | Sr. | Plymouth State | Fairfield, Conn. |
| D | Tim Larocca* | Jr. | Western New England | East Longmeadow, Mass. |
| D | Dana Leary* | Jr. | Williams | Washington, D.C. |
| M | Josh Bolton* | Sr. | Williams | Penfield, N.Y. |
| M | Derek Cece* | Sr. | Middlebury | Williamstown, Mass. |
| M | Matt Cusack | Sr. | Western Connecticut State | New Milford, Conn. |
| F | David Blum | So. | Clark | Irvington, N.Y. |
| F | Bradley Fidler | Jr. | Western Connecticut State | West Lawn, Pa. |
| F | Patrick Huffer | Jr. | Williams | Boulder, Colo. |
| F | Mike Wohl* | Jr. | Amherst | Northampton, Mass. |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown |
| GK | Nick Armington* | Sr. | Williams | Wenham, Mass. |
| D | Bryan Biederman | Jr. | Plymouth State | Holderness, N.H. |
| D | Daniel Kiernan | Jr. | Colby | Brookline, Mass. |
| D | Shelton Stewart** | Sr. | Brandeis | Clarendon, Jamaica |
| M | Kofi Oteng | Jr. | Western New England | Worcester, Mass. |
| M | Eric Scott | Jr. | Keene State | West Springfield, Mass. |
| M | Matthew Young | Sr. | Worcester Polytechnic | Manchester, Conn. |
| F | Jared Ashe | Jr. | Wesleyan | Stamford, Conn. |
| F | Mike Cooley | Fr. | Keene State | Northborough, Mass. |
| F | Paul Russo | Sr. | Western New England | Dix Hills, N.Y. |
| F | Nathan Williams | Sr. | Castleton State | East Schodack, N.Y. |
| * Indicates previous All-New England selections | ||||