| 2005 NSCAA/adidas® | ||||
| NCAA Division II Men | ||||
| All-Appalachian Region | ||||
| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown |
| GK | Tyler Baldock | Jr. | Carson-Newman | Surrey, B.C. |
| D | Kenny Crow | Sr. | Catawba College | Readers, Pa. |
| D | Jason McMillian | Sr. | Carson-Newman | Gold Coast, Australia |
| D | Richard Moody | Sr. | Carson-Newman | Stenhouse Murh, Scotland |
| M | Ben Clark | Sr. | Wingate | Chesterfield, England |
| M | Nathan Zurga | Jr. | Catawba | Troy, Mich. |
| M | Trent Weber | Sr. | Presbyterian | Atlanta, Ga. |
| F | Zay Zay Gilewala | Sr. | Catawba | Liberia |
| F | Dario Carrasco | Jr. | Carson-Newman | Malaga, Spain |
| F | Gareth Turnbull | Sr. | Catawba | Christchurch,New Zealand |
| F | Robert Dawson | Sr. | Wingate | Manchester, England |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown |
| GK | Mark Owens | So. | Presbyterian | Charleston, S.C. |
| D | Jade Jones | Sr. | Wheeling Jesuit | Grin, Trinidad |
| D | Robert Hanal | Sr. | Lenoir-Rhyne | Conley, Ga. |
| D | Makeji Bostic | So. | Davis & Elkins | Trinidad |
| M | James Lavery | So. | Wingate | Belfast, Northern Ireland |
| M | Niphon Phittayarsri | Jr. | West Virginia Wesley | Bowie, Md. |
| M | Gil Vainshtein | Jr. | Alderson-Broaddus | Toronto, Ontario |
| F | Marvin Huber | Jr. | Salem International | Natal, South Africa |
| F | Brandon Tucker | So. | Presbyterian | Denver, Colo. |
| F | Sean Regan | Sr. | Wheeling Jesuit | Wheeling, W. Va. |
| F | Luis Carrisoza | Fr. | Lenoir-Rhyne | Bergen, N.J. |