| 2005 NSCAA/adidas® | ||||
| NCAA Division II Men | ||||
| All-Great Lakes Region | ||||
| First Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown |
| GK | Nate Gibson | Sr. | Truman State | Granite City, Ill. |
| D | Nick Frederick | Sr. | Quincy | St. Louis, Mo. |
| D | Kevin Thibodeau | Jr. | SIU-Edwardsville | St. Charles, Mo. |
| D | Ben Tommerup | Sr. | Wisconsin-Parkside | Racine, Wis. |
| M | Cody Anderson | Sr. | Rockhurst | Lee's Summit, Mo. |
| M | Elliot Bradbrook | So. | Ashland | England |
| M | Martin Clayes | Sr. | Truman State | Perth, Scotland |
| F | Mike Banner | Jr. | SIU-Edwardsville | Washington, D.C. |
| F | Cathal Brady | Jr. | Lewis | Dublin, Ireland |
| F | Hagi Leboo | Fr. | Rockhurst | Nairobi, Kenya |
| F | Jacob Schramm | Sr. | Findlay | Wellington, Ohio |
| Second Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown |
| GK | Victor Perez | So. | Wisconsin-Parkside | Kenosha, Wis. |
| D | Gareth Kolkenbeck | So. | Gannon | Johannesburg, S. Africa |
| D | Rhodri Payne | Sr. | Rockhurst | Christchurch, New Zealand |
| D | Nick Staggs | Sr. | Bellarmine | Louisville, Ky. |
| M | John Matthews | Jr. | SIU-Edwardsville | Edwardsville, Ill. |
| M | Dan O'Leary | Sr. | Quincy | St. Louis, Mo. |
| M | Jason Pedra | Jr. | Mercyhurst | Mississauga, Ontario |
| F | Sean Birrell | Sr. | Truman State | Perth, Scotland |
| F | Jon Brickman | Jr. | Gannon | Mentor, Ohio |
| F | Dan Howell | Fr. | Gannon | Erie, Pa. |
| F | Victor Pacheco | Jr. | SIU-Edwardsville | Sao Luis, Brazil |
| Third Team | ||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown |
| GK | Brian Forest | Sr. | Quincy | St. Louis, Mo. |
| D | Jared Atwood | Sr. | Truman State | Lee's Summit, Mo. |
| D | Tony McCormick | Sr. | Findlay | West Chester, Pa. |
| D | Andy Tait | Jr. | Mercyhurst | Halifax, U.K. |
| M | Tony Capuro | So. | Northern Kentucky | Cincinnati, Ohio |
| M | Scott Deal | Jr. | Drury | San Antonio, Texas |
| M | Brian Higgins | Sr. | SIU-Edwardsville | St. Charles, Mo. |
| M | Dusty Shannon | Sr. | Indianapolis | Topeka, Kan. |
| F | Bojan Jovicic | So. | Wisconsin-Parkside | Milwaukee, Wis. |
| F | Chad Manning | Jr. | Bellarmine | Waterloo, Ill. |
| F | Nick Toeller | Sr. | Missouri- Rolla | Germantown, Tenn. |