| 2005 NSCAA/adidas® | ||||||||||
| NCAA Division I Men | ||||||||||
|
||||||||||
| First Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| GK | Adam Edwards | Sr. | Bucknell | Downingtown, Pa. | ||||||
| B | Jarron Brooks | So. | St. Francis (Pa.) | Mitchellville, Md. | ||||||
| B | Tim Faneck | Sr. | Bucknell | Shavertown, Pa. | ||||||
| B | Hugh McDonald | Jr. | Monmouth | Kearny, N.J. | ||||||
| M | Anthony Donatelli | Sr. | Temple | Glenside, Pa. | ||||||
| M | David Walters | Sr. | Penn State | Hunlock Creek, Pa. | ||||||
| M | Adam Williamson | Sr. | Lehigh | Petersburg, N.J. | ||||||
| F | Scott Hawkins | So. | Lafayette | Whippany, N.J. | ||||||
| F | Sascha Kjlestan | Sr. | Seton Hall | Huntington Beach, Calif.. | ||||||
| F | Simon Omekanda | Jr. | Penn State | Rochester Hills, Mich. | ||||||
| F | James Stevens | Sr. | Lehigh | Clifton, Va. | ||||||
| Second Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| GK | Art Satterwhite | Sr. | Monmouth | Somerset, N.J. | ||||||
| B | Donnie Mayard | Jr. | Fairleigh Dickinson | Laval, Quebec | ||||||
| B | Luke Sullivan | So. | Lafayette | Slingerland, N.Y. | ||||||
| B | Jameson Wunsch | Jr. | Princeton | Londonderry, N.H. | ||||||
| M | Nadav Gottesman | Sr. | Fairleigh Dickinson | Haifa, Israel | ||||||
| M | Nick LaBrocca | Jr. | Rutgers | Howell, N.J. | ||||||
| M | Travis MacKenzie | So. | Duquesne | Carnegie, Pa. | ||||||
| M | Marco Orias | Jr. | St. Peter's | Newark, N.J. | ||||||
| F | Juan Gavaria | So. | St. Peter's | Elizabeth, N.J. | ||||||
| F | Jarrod Smith | Jr. | West Virginia | Havelock North, New Zealand | ||||||
| F | Darren Spicer | Sr. | Princeton | Diamond Bar, Calif. | ||||||
| Third Team | ||||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | ||||||
| GK | Boris Pardo | Sr. | Seton Hall | |||||||
| B | Allan Brown | Jr. | Robert Morris | |||||||
| B | Devon McTavish | Sr. | West Virginia | |||||||
| B | John O'Reilly | Jr. | Lehigh | |||||||
| M | Brian Devlin | Sr. | Penn State | |||||||
| M | Derek Hobson | So. | Pennsylvania | |||||||
| M | Teddy Nizolek | Jr. | Seton Hall | |||||||
| F | Alejandro Bedoya | Fr. | Fairleigh Dickinson | |||||||
| F | Eliseo Guisfredi | Fr. | Seton Hall | |||||||
| F | Mike Klein | Fr. | Pennsylvania | |||||||
| F | Steve Mellor | Sr. | Duquesne | |||||||