|
|||||||||
| First Team | |||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | |||||
| K | Dustin Walker | Sr. | Penn State-Behrend | Apollo, Pa. | |||||
| D | Jeremy Fischer | Sr. | Kenyon | Los Angeles, Calif. | |||||
| D | Eric Laipple | Sr. | Ohio Wesleyan | Westerville, Ohio | |||||
| D | Beau Sorg | Sr. | DePauw | Fort Wayne, Ind. | |||||
| M | Ryan Browne | Sr. | Carnegie Mellon | Jefferson Hills, Pa. | |||||
| M | Peter Shorten | Sr. | Denison | Hudson, Ohio | |||||
| M | Travis Wall | So. | Ohio Wesleyan | Columbus, Ohio | |||||
| F | Skylar Dum | Sr. | Oberlin | Milford, Mich. | |||||
| F | Ricky Griffin | Sr. | Carnegie Mellon | Hastings-on-Hudson, N.Y. | |||||
| F | Steven McCarthy | Sr. | Capital | Centerville, Ohio | |||||
| F | Tyler Wall | Jr. | Ohio Wesleyan | Columbus, Ohio | |||||
| Second Team | |||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | |||||
| K | Kevin Donahue | Sr. | Denison | Riverside, Conn. | |||||
| D | Matt Giannetti | Sr. | Ohio Wesleyan | Verona, N.J. | |||||
| D | Dan Schade | Sr. | Ohio Northern | Westlake, Ohio | |||||
| D | Nirosha Wimalasena | So. | Case Western Reserve | Cincinnati, Ohio | |||||
| M | Vincent Bell | So. | Case Western Reserve | Parma Heights, Ohio | |||||
| M | Felix Hoffmann | Jr. | Kenyon | Bergheim, Germany | |||||
| M | Daniel McCarthy | So | Capital | Centerville, Ohio | |||||
| F | Bannet Asingura | Jr. | Earlham | Mbarara, Uganda | |||||
| F | Rhys Evans | Sr. | Rose Hulman | Lake Bluff, Ill. | |||||
| F | Pat Lutz | Sr. | Carnegie Mellon | Lebanon, Pa | |||||
| F | Dan Otanicar | Jr. | Ohio Northern | Wadsworth, Ohio | |||||
| Third Team | |||||||||
| Pos. | Name | Year | School | Hometown | |||||
| K | Raymond Kramer III | Sr. | Transylvania | Versailles, Ky. | |||||
| D | Ayepede Adedapo | Sr. | Marietta | Gahanna, Ohio | |||||
| D | Kevin Jones | Jr. | Transylvania | Middletown, Ohio | |||||
| D | David Mason | Sr. | Hiram | Akron, Ohio | |||||
| D | Nate Smith | Sr. | Baldwin-Wallace | Ashland, Ohio | |||||
| M | Keith Danagarembwa | So. | Kenyon | Bulawayo, Zimbabwe | |||||
| M | Jeff Grater | Jr. | Baldwin-Wallace | Stow, Ohio | |||||
| M | Aaron Meehl | So. | Penn State Behrend | North East, Pa. | |||||
| F | Joseph DeSteffano | Fr. | Penn State-Altoona | Solebury, Pa. | |||||
| F | Austin Hall | So. | Centre | Indianapolis, Ind. | |||||
| F | Christian Huelsman | So. | Ohio Northern | Wellington, Ohio | |||||